Home Knowledges Tanzanite VS Amethyst: Which is More Valuable?

Tanzanite VS Amethyst: Which is More Valuable?

by Madonna

In the captivating world of gemstones, tanzanite and amethyst are two distinct treasures, each possessing its unique allure and mystique. While both gems are celebrated for their vivid colors and striking beauty, they belong to different mineral families and have distinct characteristics that contribute to their value. In this comprehensive article, we embark on a journey to explore the enchanting realms of tanzanite and amethyst, unveiling their origins, properties, and the factors that determine their worth. By the end of this exploration, you will have a deeper understanding of the Tanzanite vs. Amethyst debate and which gem may reign supreme in terms of value.

The Resplendence of Tanzanite

Tanzanite, a relative newcomer to the world of gemstones, made its debut in 1967 when it was discovered in the foothills of Mount Kilimanjaro in Tanzania. Its striking blue-to-violet hues have since enthralled gem enthusiasts, and it has earned a place among the world’s most sought-after gems. Tanzanite belongs to the mineral species zoisite and is celebrated for its unique color-changing ability, known as pleochroism, which imparts a spectrum of colors when viewed from different angles and lighting conditions.


Origins and Sources

Tanzanite’s exclusivity lies in its single-source origin—Tanzania. More specifically, it is found in the Merelani Hills region of northern Tanzania. This limited geographic occurrence adds an element of rarity to tanzanite, making it a gemstone prized for its scarcity.


The Color Spectrum of Tanzanite

Tanzanite’s allure hinges on its enchanting color range, which transitions from deep blue to violet and exhibits intermediate hues of lavender and periwinkle. The richness and depth of tanzanite’s color depend on the presence of trace elements, primarily vanadium. The most prized tanzanite gemstones display a vivid and pure blue hue without any hints of green or gray undertones.


Clarity and Transparency

High-quality tanzanite gemstones possess excellent clarity, often appearing nearly free of visible inclusions or blemishes. This transparency allows light to penetrate the gem, enhancing its brilliance and overall visual appeal.

Durability and Hardness

Tanzanite ranks 6.5 to 7 on the Mohs scale of mineral hardness, making it suitable for a variety of jewelry settings. However, due to its relatively lower hardness compared to other gemstones like sapphire or diamond, it requires careful handling and protection from scratches.

Tanzanite’s Commercial Appeal

Tanzanite’s beauty, rarity, and limited source have propelled it into the world of high-end jewelry. It is often used in a range of jewelry styles, from engagement rings and necklaces to earrings and bracelets. In addition to its exquisite aesthetics, tanzanite’s unique color-changing property adds an element of intrigue, making it a favorite among collectors and connoisseurs.

The Splendor of Amethyst

Amethyst, on the other hand, is a gemstone with a rich history that spans millennia. It belongs to the quartz family and is renowned for its captivating purple coloration, ranging from delicate lilac to deep royal purple. The name “amethyst” is derived from the Greek words “amethystos,” which translate to “not intoxicated.” In ancient times, amethyst was believed to have the power to prevent drunkenness and promote sobriety, making it a symbol of clarity and wisdom.

Origins and Sources

Amethyst is found in various locations across the globe, and its availability is relatively widespread compared to tanzanite. Some notable sources of amethyst include Brazil, Uruguay, Zambia, Russia, Madagascar, India, and the United States.

The Palette of Amethyst

Amethyst’s charm lies in its captivating shades of purple. The quality and value of amethyst are often determined by factors such as the depth of color, clarity, and brilliance. Deep and saturated purples are highly prized, while lighter shades, known as “Rose de France” amethyst, have their own delicate appeal.

Clarity and Transparency

Amethyst, like tanzanite, can range from transparent to translucent. High-quality amethyst gemstones are nearly free of visible inclusions, allowing light to pass through with remarkable clarity. This transparency enhances the gem’s overall brilliance.

Durability and Hardness

Amethyst is a relatively durable gemstone, ranking 7 on the Mohs scale of hardness. This level of hardness makes it suitable for use in various types of jewelry, including rings, earrings, necklaces, and bracelets. However, it is essential to handle amethyst jewelry with care to prevent scratches and damage.

Amethyst’s Endless Appeal

Amethyst’s enduring popularity stems from its versatility and accessibility. It has been used in jewelry for centuries and continues to be a favorite choice for both contemporary and vintage designs. Amethyst’s soothing purple hues make it suitable for various jewelry styles and settings, from classic to modern.

See Also: Amethyst Placement for Wealth: Harnessing the Power of Crystal

Tanzanite vs. Amethyst: Factors that Determine Value

To compare the value of tanzanite and amethyst, it’s crucial to consider several factors that influence the worth of each gemstone:

1. Rarity and Origin:

Tanzanite’s limited source, originating solely from Tanzania, contributes to its rarity and exclusivity. Amethyst, on the other hand, is found in numerous locations worldwide, making it more abundant and accessible.

2. Color and Color Intensity:

Both tanzanite and amethyst derive much of their value from their color. For tanzanite, a rich and pure blue hue is highly sought after. In contrast, amethyst’s value is determined by the depth and saturation of its purple color. Tanzanite’s color-changing ability adds to its appeal.

3. Clarity and Transparency:

High-quality gemstones of both tanzanite and amethyst possess excellent clarity, with minimal inclusions or blemishes. Gems with superior transparency and brilliance are typically more valuable.

4. Size and Carat Weight:

The size of the gemstone, often expressed in carats, significantly affects its value. Larger, high-quality tanzanite and amethyst gemstones command higher prices due to their rarity.

5. Jewelry Market Demand:

Consumer preferences and market trends influence the demand and value of gemstones. Tanzanite’s unique color-changing property and limited source have made it a sought-after gem for collectors and jewelry enthusiasts. Amethyst’s timeless appeal and affordability make it a popular choice for various jewelry styles.

See Also: How to Wear an Amethyst Bracelet: A Guide to Adorning Wrist

Conclusion: Tanzanite vs. Amethyst

In the eternal debate of tanzanite vs. amethyst, determining which gemstone is more valuable ultimately depends on individual preferences and priorities. Tanzanite’s rarity, enchanting color range, and color-changing property position it as a high-end gemstone sought by collectors and those seeking unique and precious jewelry. Amethyst, with its widespread availability, captivating shades of purple, and affordability, offers an accessible and enduring option for a wide range of jewelry styles.


1. Which gemstone is considered more precious for collectors?

Tanzanite is often regarded as more precious among collectors due to its limited source and exceptional color-changing ability. Collectors are drawn to its rarity and unique qualities, making it a prized addition to gemstone collections.

2. Can amethyst be as valuable as tanzanite?

While tanzanite is generally considered more valuable due to its rarity, exceptional amethyst gemstones with deep, saturated purple colors, excellent clarity, and large sizes can also be valuable. However, in most cases, tanzanite tends to command higher prices.

3. Are there any specific jewelry trends or designs that favor one gemstone over the other?

Tanzanite’s color-changing property and unique hues make it a popular choice for one-of-a-kind, high-end jewelry designs. It is often featured in custom pieces and statement jewelry. Amethyst’s affordability and versatility make it a favored gemstone for a wide range of jewelry styles, from classic to contemporary.

4. Which gemstone is more suitable for everyday wear in jewelry?

Amethyst, with its durability (Mohs hardness of 7), is a more suitable choice for everyday wear in jewelry, such as rings and bracelets. Tanzanite, while relatively hard (Mohs hardness of 6.5-7), may require extra care due to its lower hardness compared to other gemstones like sapphire or diamond.

5. Do tanzanite and amethyst have metaphysical properties that affect their value?

Both tanzanite and amethyst are associated with metaphysical properties. Tanzanite is believed to enhance spiritual growth and clarity, while amethyst is often associated with tranquility and emotional balance. While these properties can enhance their perceived value to some individuals, they are not factors that significantly affect their market value.


You May Also Like


Giacoloredstones is a colored gem portal. The main columns are Ruby, Sapphire, Emerald, Tourmaline, Aquamarine, Tanzanite, Amethyst, Garnet, Turquoise, Knowledges, News, etc.【Contact us: [email protected]

© 2023 Copyright